Not as well unfortunately. It's a different kind of plastic. If you drink juice, those bottles work. What you might want to try is going to your local market, not walmart and go to the bakery and ask for their used icing buckets. They usually give them away or charge a buck for them. If they are free, you'll have to wash them, but no biggie and the lids fit nice and tight. I use these for everything and it's uncle. I don't mess with the mylar and O2 thingies, that's just me. I've not had a problem. I just toss a few bay leaves in whatever it is I'm storing and pop the lid on, good to go.