There's another vehicle that deserves consideration here, actually two more. If we're looking at 10 year old vehicles, the Nissan Pathfinder and especially the Nissan Xterra deserve a mention. They're more rugged than any unibody framed vehicle and the Xterra is well known for having a great 4x4 capability. The reliability is just a step below Toyota and the price will be cheaper. I wouldn't be afraid of an Xterra at all...